Sagaspedia
PTES
Cover of The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes
The first cases (1887–1894) · England, 1880s to 1891

The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes

The recap and the What changed on screen section are hidden. Turn SPOILER ALERT on to read them; turn it off to hide them again.

Holmes's past cases, the debut of Mycroft and the clash with Professor Moriarty

Pages272 pagesWhere to buyAmazonIn your readingnot read yet
Build my reading plan

Watch it: Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows →

Do you need to read it?

Yes. It's in the Main story, the list of only what moves the plot forward to the end of the saga.

Where it falls in the order

  • Main story3 of 5
  • Everything4 of 9
Spoilers for this title

Quick recap

The stories of 1892 and 1893, with cases from Holmes's past such as "Silver Blaze", where the racehorse vanishes and the dog doesn't bark, and "The Greek Interpreter", which introduces Mycroft, the detective's older brother. The book ends with "The Final Problem", in which Professor Moriarty, a mathematician and London's crime boss, steps in, and the chase takes Holmes and Dr. Watson to Switzerland. The story ends at the Reichenbach Falls, in an ending Doyle meant to be the last.

No spoilersOpens once you mark the title as seen.
4 what changed on screen

What changed on screen

  1. ChangeA one-story villain

    In the book, Moriarty appears in person only in "The Final Problem". The 2011 film makes him the villain of a whole feature.

    source ↗
  2. ChangeWatson away from the falls

    In the story, a false note about a dying Englishwoman draws Watson away from Holmes at the falls. In the film, Watson travels with Holmes for much of the trip.

    source ↗
  3. ChangeMycroft grows

    Mycroft first appears in "The Greek Interpreter", in this book, and briefly in "The Final Problem". In the film he is Stephen Fry, with bigger scenes.

    source ↗
  4. ChangeChess instead of a note

    In the story, Watson never sees the duel: he only finds Holmes's farewell note and the signs of a struggle by the falls. In the film, Holmes and Moriarty play chess on a balcony during a peace conference.

    source ↗
No spoilersThe easter eggs give away parts of the title. They open once you mark it as seen.

Comments

Original text by Sagaspedia. Posters: The Movie Database (TMDB); character photos via Wikipedia. This site uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB. All trademarks and titles mentioned belong to their respective owners. Streaming availability may change.

As an Amazon Associate, Sagaspedia earns from qualifying purchases.