Quick recap
Father Jud Duplenticy, a former boxer, is transferred to an upstate New York parish run by Monsignor Jefferson Wicks. On Good Friday, Wicks is found dead in the church with a knife in his back, in a room locked from the inside. Jud, who had threatened him, becomes the prime suspect. The police call in detective Benoit Blanc, who believes he is innocent. The two investigate the parishioners, an old priest's inheritance and a secret that seems supernatural. The mood is darker and the setting far plainer than the previous film's island.
