An Ugly with doubts
Shay shows up in Tally's life right after Peris turns Pretty. They become friends fast, but they think differently. Tally is counting down to the surgery. Shay finds it strange that everyone comes out of the operation the same, inside and out.
She has a plan: run away to the Smoke, a free community far from the city, led by David. Shay asks Tally to come along. Tally says no.
To Shay, the city buys people's peace with a pretty face. She can't explain everything the operation does, but she senses that whoever comes back from it isn't the same person, and Peris is living proof of that for Tally.